Thursday, March 10, 2011

Behaviorism

In this week's post I'll take a look at how a couple different strategies fit in with behaviorism.  The two strategies presented this week were "Reinforcing Effort" and "Homework and Practice."

Showing effort is one factor that contributes to student success; in fact, it's the only one they can control (Pitler, Hubbell, Kuhn, & Malenoski, 2007).  What we need to do then, as teachers and role models, is impart to our students how important it is to show effort in everything they do.  One of the ways that Pitler et al. recommend to do this is to have students keep track of their own effort using some kind of rubric and tracking sheet (2007).  This will provide the students will some immediate feedback, which could fit into the reward or the punishment aspect, things that are critical to the behaviorist point of view according to Dr. Orey (Laureate Education, Inc., 2010).  I try to emphasize to my students all the time how important it is to show effort in what they do.  When I assign homework, I grade on completion.  If the students have attempted all the problems and shown their work, they receive full credit.  They get a chance to correct and ask questions every day.  I also tell them that showing all work on extended response questions and multi-step problems can possibly earn them points and partial credit, which can be the difference between passing and failing.  I also make sure they show effort in following rules and procedures set in the class and school, which all goes along with our Positive Behavior Support (PBS) system.  Through some operant conditioning and classical conditioning mentioned by Dr. Orey (Laureate Education, Inc., 2010), they get into the swing of the everyday routine pretty easily, even though we don't think of using classical conditioning very often in school.  We can definitely see examples of it, however, when something as simple as the bell starts to ring.  The students know that it signifies either the beginning or end of class and there are certain things that they must do at that point.  I am also thinking of trying the effort rubric that was included in this week's reading.

I found a couple of rather fun examples of classical conditioning on YouTube that I thought I'd share here:




I loved this one! It was done at Bowling Green State University about 20 miles from me.


The second strategy that was presented this week was Homework and Practice.  One of the recommendations that Pitler et al. mention with homework is to vary the feedback (2007) which goes right back to what Dr. Orey says about providing the reinforcement to students, whether it is used as reward or punishment (Laureate Education, Inc., 2010).  As a math teacher, I give homework almost every day and it is used for practice and reinforcement.  The students are told at the beginning of the year that if they complete their homework and ask questions when necessary, they will do well on tests since the questions they are assigned are almost identical to what they will see on a test.  Usually, it takes the students a test or two to figure out that I was telling them the truth and that they need to pay close attention to the homework problems that are assigned.

Both of these strategies are very closely tied to behaviorism and exhibit many of its characteristics.

Laureate Education, Inc. (Executive Producer). (2010). Program four. Behaviorist learning theory [Webcast]. Bridging learning theory, instruction and technology. Baltimore, MD: Author.

Pitler, H., Hubbell, E., Kuhn, M., & Malenoski, K. (2007). Using technology with classroom 
        instruction that works. Alexandria, VA: ASCD.

5 comments:

  1. John:
    Your views on homework are much along the same lines as mine, I grade my students on effort when it comes to homework, it is important that students have a reason to complete homework, and at the very least work on attempting problems. I like that you mentioned the idea of the teacher as the role model. It is incredibly important that we as educators are positive role models to our students, and put all of our effort into working with our students every day. I also thought that it was incredibly interesting that you mentioned the idea of classical conditioning with the ringing of class change bells, this is something that I have never thought of, however it is true classical conditioning.

    p.s. I like your embedded youtube videos.

    ReplyDelete
  2. John excellent analysis! I also try to grade on completion when applicable. I love the idea of having students self-assessing their effort in your class. Is this a daily self-assessment? Furthermore, is there any reward (points) for them filling out their effort tracking sheets? What are your thoughts on doing this with only the students that are struggling in a one on one setting as an intervention method?

    ReplyDelete
  3. John, I also grade my student’s homework on completion, or basically participation. Do you have them check their own solutions as well or are they read aloud? I have begun to have students check their own solutions by posting them in the room so they may check work at their own pace. I give small quizzes frequently to assess each of the benchmark skills for myself to grade. Do you feel that some of this practices would be better done on computers or online applications, or do you feel that these mathematical processes are better done on paper? Also, I was wondering how much of the total grade percentage you make your homework worth.

    Thanks,

    Mike

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't have anything new to add, just wanted to say that I enjoyed your post - both the content and the fun videos.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I haven't actually tried the rubric yet, but I'm anxious to see how it works. And, as a department, we decided that homework would count as 20% of the overall grade for all math teachers.

    ReplyDelete